Plus, I know very well how hard it is to write a video editor that actually works as expected (hint: more complex than developing something like Firefox). I’m sure it was hard work, and I know he’s a cool guy in the few times we have corresponded during the past year. I’m not trying to trash 1.5 years of work for the main developer. It is infinitely more unstable than either KDEnLive or PiTiVi (editors that don’t fair well either, but they’re like bright stars compared to OpenShot). Overall, I have to say that this is the most problematic application I have encountered in the last 3-4 years. And when I tried to just export a small clip, it exported out the file (Vimeo HD template), but the app crashed right on the last step so the produced file was not really playable. Freezing in particular was so common, that I’m unable to write a more traditional review where the process follows a specific editing workflow - simply because editing anything serious was not really feasible.
IS OPENSHOT SOFTWARE SAFE TO USE PC
Previewing, adding clips, adding plugins or transitions, all eventually resulted in either freezing or crashing (and no, there’s nothing wrong with my PC or Ubuntu installation). mov file (a file that earlier did work with the app).
At one instance I even locked up the app by trying to open my Desktop folder to load a. Previewing videos either in the timeline or not it would lock up the app quite easily, and in some case it locked up my whole X11 (had to kill X). I’m afraid that doing actual work with that editor is out of the question: I’d get about one lockup every minute! Application freeze after freeze.
And when I imported just a single mp3 file, there was still major crackling. In addition to terrible video performance, there was the audio that was misbehaving: there was audio crackling during ALL videos. In addition, I was able to reproducibly crash the application using a WMV VGA video, and a 720/30p MJPEG AVI from the latest Olympus dSLR. Even a 320×176 OGV file was bleeding framerate. Previewing speed while on the media bin was as expected, but when dragged in the timeline I couldn’t find a single instance where the video would preview smoothly. The application and its custom ffmpeg it used was able to load all file formats I threw at it, but it was super slow. I tried every possible format out there: XViD, MKV, h.264 in MP4/MOV/MTS. Similarly, the “slicing” options, which automatically cuts into pieces a clip in the timeline, is missing the point: it doesn’t scale, usability-wise. Instead of being able to use keyframes within a clip, we can only use them at beginning or end, and they won’t work with plugins, but only with position of the clip in the preview plane. Where are the 3-way color correctors, contrast, color isolation, etc?Īdditionally, some more advanced features, like keyframes, are architected in a non-useful way. Additionally, speaking for me, the real value of post-processing footage is in color grading, not in these silly and super-cliche spiral transitions that are so ’80s. Just like any other Linux video editor out there it’s using the frei0r third party plugin system, which are basic, and buggy. There’s also a bug in the AppleTV exporting dialog where it exports at 720/30p, while the AppleTV can’t do more than 720/24p.Įxcept “blur”, “brightness”, “deinterlace”, “gamma”, and “white balance”, most of the rest of the effects are not very useful. There are a number of templates, but the project properties and exporting dialog don’t offer enough flexibility. The developer of OpenShot must optimize his interface to not take unnecessary space.Īnother gripe is the fact that you can’t set the aspect ratio of your footage and de-interlacing project-wide. On an XGA monitor, the preview screen gets reduced to a stamp-size video, while PiTiVi fairs way better in that department.
Additionally, the “Video Preview” tab, the preview and timeline toolbar icons, and the “Timeline – Sequence 1” tabs take way too much space.
Transitions are working properly if you put the clips on different tracks, but they didn’t do what I needed when I overlapped two clips and placed a transition on top. Right-clicking on the clips in the timeline will load a dialog where you can control speed, plugins, and more. When I loaded the app, I was provided with a pretty traditional and easy to understand video editing playground: files, transitions, effects on one side, a preview window on the right, and the timeline on the bottom with tools such as “cutting”. Given that I’m longing for a usable Linux video editor since 2003, and given that OpenShot version 1.0 had just been released, I naturally gave it a go, by also downloading its provided dependencies on my Ubuntu Linux 9.10. I followed the hype: Reddit, Slashdot’s front page, months of thumbs up on my blog and various video forums by Linux users for OpenShot.
0 kommentar(er)
